The problem is that this an almost impossible deal to get an apples to apples comparison. That is way I tried to simplify it some posts back.
Stan Weiss wrote: ↑Mon Nov 06, 2017 1:26 pm
Lets simplify this. Which Is Faster? - 600 hp @ 6200 RPM or 600 hp @ 6200 RPM
Based on the very limited information I have given I would say they are the same.
Now how about we talk about what differences in the engines would make one faster than the other.
I will start by wanting to know what peak torque was and at what RPM for each engine.
Stan
Even here it is probably impossible to find dyno sheets that match at any given point.
This is the closest I could find.
Stan
Engine_Size_=__360.4219_ci
Dyno_Barometric_Pressure_=_29.32_-_Dyno_Vapor_Pressure_=_0.15_-_Dyno_Air_Temperature_=_65.0
_________________________________Fuel___________UnCorr__UnCorr_UnCorr_Correct___A/F
__RPM___Horse__Torque___BMEP____lb/hr_____BSFC______HP__Torque___BMEP__Factor__Ratio____SCFM____VE%
_3500___372.1___558.4__233.6___161.27____.4500___358.4___537.8__225.0__1.0384__10.70___376.8__106.9
_3600___381.8___556.9__233.0___162.67____.4400___369.7___539.4__225.7__1.0326__10.70___380.0__104.8
_3700___393.2___558.2__233.5___162.51____.4300___377.9___536.5__224.5__1.0405__10.90___386.8__103.8
_3800___403.7___558.0__233.5___163.44____.4200___389.1___537.8__225.0__1.0375__11.00___392.5__102.6
_3900___415.2___559.1__233.9___164.11____.4100___400.3___539.0__225.5__1.0374__11.20___401.3__102.2
_4000___427.9___561.9__235.1___163.37____.4000___408.4___536.3__224.4__1.0477__11.50___410.2__101.8
_4100___439.0___562.3__235.3___164.06____.3900___420.7___538.9__225.5__1.0435__11.70___419.1__101.5
_4200___450.6___563.5__235.8___165.31____.3800___435.0___544.0__227.6__1.0358__11.80___425.9__100.7
_4300___462.4___564.7__236.3___166.98____.3800___439.4___536.7__224.6__1.0522__12.00___437.5__101.0
_4400___473.2___564.9__236.3___168.61____.3700___455.7___543.9__227.6__1.0385__12.20___449.1__101.4
_4500___483.7___564.6__236.2___170.31____.3700___460.3___537.2__224.8__1.0509__12.20___453.7__100.1
_4600___494.2___564.3__236.1___173.34____.3600___481.5___549.7__230.0__1.0264__12.30___465.5__100.5
_4700___503.8___563.0__235.5___175.57____.3600___487.7___545.0__228.0__1.0330__12.40___475.3__100.4
_4800___514.0___562.4__235.3___176.89____.3600___491.4___537.6__224.9__1.0460__12.60___486.7__100.7
_4900___524.4___562.1__235.2___179.14____.3600___497.6___533.4__223.2__1.0539__12.80___500.6__101.5
_5000___533.8___560.7__234.6___181.31____.3500___518.0___544.1__227.7__1.0304__12.80___506.7__100.6
_5100___542.8___559.0__233.9___182.83____.3500___522.4___537.9__225.1__1.0391__13.00___519.0__101.0
_5200___550.3___555.8__232.5___186.26____.3500___532.2___537.5__224.9__1.0340__13.10___532.8__101.7
_5300___556.9___551.8__230.9___188.93____.3500___539.8___534.9__223.8__1.0316__13.20___544.5__102.0
_5400___564.4___549.0__229.7___192.57____.3600___534.9___520.3__217.7__1.0552__13.20___555.0__102.1
_5500___571.2___545.4__228.2___195.12____.3600___542.0___517.6__216.5__1.0538__13.20___562.4__101.5
_5600___576.2___540.4__226.1___197.94____.3600___549.8___515.7__215.8__1.0479__13.20___570.5__101.2
_5700___580.6___535.0__223.8___200.64____.3600___557.3___513.5__214.9__1.0417__13.30___582.6__101.5
_5800___586.0___530.6__222.0___202.94____.3600___563.7___510.5__213.6__1.0395__13.30___589.3__100.9
_5900___592.1___527.0__220.5___204.12____.3600___567.0___504.7__211.2__1.0442__13.40___597.2__100.5
_6000___593.9___519.9__217.5___209.41____.3700___566.0___495.4__207.3__1.0493__13.30___608.1__100.6
_6100___598.3___515.2__215.5___213.31____.3700___576.5___496.4__207.7__1.0378__13.20___614.8__100.1
_6200___603.5___511.2__213.9___216.38____.3700___584.8___495.4__207.3__1.0319__13.10___618.9___99.1
_6300___602.7___502.5__210.2___220.62____.3800___580.6___484.0__202.5__1.0382__13.00___626.2___98.7
AVG:
_4900___510.1___549.2__229.8___183.10____.3769___489.9___527.6__220.8__________12.42___499.6__101.4
MIN:
_3500___372.1___502.5__210.2___161.27____.3500___358.4___484.0__202.5__________10.70___376.8___98.7
MAX:
_6300___603.5___564.9__236.3___220.62____.4500___584.8___549.7__230.0__________13.40___626.2__106.9
Average_based_on_=_29_points