What happens at the “choke” point?
Moderator: Team
What happens at the “choke” point?
I’ve been playing with some of the calculators on the Wallace website, as always trying to learn more.
What happens to airflow, and power once you reach the smallest choke point of the intake tract? Air goes turbulent? No increase in flow? Power peaks and then starts dropping?
For example...per AFR’s website, their 165 sbf Head has a mcsa of 1.935”. Per the calculator, a .040” over 351w with this head will choke at approximately 5600 rpms. Does this mean that with appropriate supporting hardware that 5600-ish should be the power peak? What happens when you put bigger supporting parts like a tunnel ram, giant cam, etc? Power still peaks at 5600-ish but just drops off slower?
The AFR 165 is advertised as 250cfm@.550”, which per another calculator this will support up to 475hp. Engines this size don’t make that kind of power at 5600 rpms without nitrous or some sort of forced induction. So what’s the deal here? I’m assuming part of this discrepancy is because engines don’t pull a steady 28” of depression?
What happens to airflow, and power once you reach the smallest choke point of the intake tract? Air goes turbulent? No increase in flow? Power peaks and then starts dropping?
For example...per AFR’s website, their 165 sbf Head has a mcsa of 1.935”. Per the calculator, a .040” over 351w with this head will choke at approximately 5600 rpms. Does this mean that with appropriate supporting hardware that 5600-ish should be the power peak? What happens when you put bigger supporting parts like a tunnel ram, giant cam, etc? Power still peaks at 5600-ish but just drops off slower?
The AFR 165 is advertised as 250cfm@.550”, which per another calculator this will support up to 475hp. Engines this size don’t make that kind of power at 5600 rpms without nitrous or some sort of forced induction. So what’s the deal here? I’m assuming part of this discrepancy is because engines don’t pull a steady 28” of depression?
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
VE starts dropping, power levels off.
Power may begin to drop soon after, or hold-on for quite a ways up. Depends on the cam and manifolds.
Power may begin to drop soon after, or hold-on for quite a ways up. Depends on the cam and manifolds.
-
- HotPass
- Posts: 3446
- Joined: Sat Feb 23, 2013 5:42 pm
- Location:
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
No more mass can get through the orfice despite greater depression on the cylinder side. Eventually pumping losses catch up and power starts to nose over.
However, plenty of race engine with sonic restrictors for rules (or be it some sort of porting limitation, choke limitation, etc.) all make power well above where the restrictor goes sonic, it's about managing the drop. Run as much compression as you can, careful selection of cam timing, and the header design is a huge player.
However, plenty of race engine with sonic restrictors for rules (or be it some sort of porting limitation, choke limitation, etc.) all make power well above where the restrictor goes sonic, it's about managing the drop. Run as much compression as you can, careful selection of cam timing, and the header design is a huge player.
-Bob
-
- Guru
- Posts: 1575
- Joined: Mon Apr 04, 2011 8:54 pm
- Location: central Florida
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
Bob do the NASCAR guys run smaller header tubes with the restrictor plate. Mark H
-
- HotPass
- Posts: 3446
- Joined: Sat Feb 23, 2013 5:42 pm
- Location:
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
I don't think so, that's a question for Calvin, Warp, Pro-Header (though I haven't seen him on here in a long time).swampbuggy wrote: ↑Sat Jun 23, 2018 9:17 pm Bob do the NASCAR guys run smaller header tubes with the restrictor plate. Mark H
Not that I'm in the market, but I do frequently search and see 1 3/4" primary NASCAR take-offs popping up on Ebay from time to time (typical is 1 7/8"). Not sure if these are test pieces or restrictor plate pieces.
-Bob
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
So it sounds like the choke point may not necessarily be the power peak, but probably real close on a street type engine because the pumping losses will start climbing rapidly at that point?hoffman900 wrote: ↑Sat Jun 23, 2018 9:09 pm No more mass can get through the orfice despite greater depression on the cylinder side. Eventually pumping losses catch up and power starts to nose over.
However, plenty of race engine with sonic restrictors for rules (or be it some sort of porting limitation, choke limitation, etc.) all make power well above where the restrictor goes sonic, it's about managing the drop. Run as much compression as you can, careful selection of cam timing, and the header design is a huge player.
-
- Guru
- Posts: 1980
- Joined: Sat Mar 08, 2008 3:08 pm
- Location: Minneapolis
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
It's often much more about WHERE the choke point is located. An mCSA located out by the PR pinch can easily be mitigated with wider SSR floor width, thinned/shortened guides and blown out bowl sizes. Whereas an mCSA shortly BEFORE, AT, or OVER the SSR will kill peak and drop over the proverbial cliff much more quickly.travis wrote: ↑Sat Jun 23, 2018 9:53 pmSo it sounds like the choke point may not necessarily be the power peak, but probably real close on a street type engine because the pumping losses will start climbing rapidly at that point?hoffman900 wrote: ↑Sat Jun 23, 2018 9:09 pm No more mass can get through the orfice despite greater depression on the cylinder side. Eventually pumping losses catch up and power starts to nose over.
However, plenty of race engine with sonic restrictors for rules (or be it some sort of porting limitation, choke limitation, etc.) all make power well above where the restrictor goes sonic, it's about managing the drop. Run as much compression as you can, careful selection of cam timing, and the header design is a huge player.
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
What happens at the “choke” point?... It Chokes!
Sorry I couldn't resist!
Sorry I couldn't resist!
Please Note!
THE ABOVE POST IN NO WAY REFLECTS THE VIEWS OF SPEED TALK OR IT'S MEMBERS AND SHOULD BE VIEWED AS ENTERTAINMENT ONLY...Thanks, The Management!
THE ABOVE POST IN NO WAY REFLECTS THE VIEWS OF SPEED TALK OR IT'S MEMBERS AND SHOULD BE VIEWED AS ENTERTAINMENT ONLY...Thanks, The Management!
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
So your saying I’m making this more complicated than it needs to be? Well...I’ve been known to do that
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
Possibly but I think the answers that come from it will give people areas to explore.
It's just that when I see a headline I have an instant smart @ss comment pop into my head in response and this time I failed to restrain my self.
Please Note!
THE ABOVE POST IN NO WAY REFLECTS THE VIEWS OF SPEED TALK OR IT'S MEMBERS AND SHOULD BE VIEWED AS ENTERTAINMENT ONLY...Thanks, The Management!
THE ABOVE POST IN NO WAY REFLECTS THE VIEWS OF SPEED TALK OR IT'S MEMBERS AND SHOULD BE VIEWED AS ENTERTAINMENT ONLY...Thanks, The Management!
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
Well first off there probably isn't a well defined choke point in most cylinder heads. In a lab you might be able to create a choke point with a sharp edged orifice or some sort of lab grade type of device, but cylinder heads are fairly complex shapes.
The simple calculators like you'll find on the Wallace page just give you an approximation, they don't really define how the engine is going to work. You can prove that by comparing a 23 degree cast iron Chevy head that has the same CSA as a high port 15 or 18 degree head. The high port head will make a lot more power even though the CSA is the same. The Wallace calculator doesn't take that into account. Shape is really important when talking about choke point.
Think of it in aero terms. Coefficient of drag is a different factor than frontal area. You can have a small car that has high drag numbers or you can have a big car with good drag numbers. The CSA is just the frontal area term. You still need to know shape before you know how the port is going to work.
Short summary is don't pay too much attention to CSA and choke point unless you have a well refined head program. If you are a NASCAR shop and all of your heads have the same shape but the CSA varies from head to head then you probably can figure out what the choke point will be. If you're just picking random heads out of the Summit catalog for a bracket race car then the calculated choke point isn't going to be all that accurate of a number.
The simple calculators like you'll find on the Wallace page just give you an approximation, they don't really define how the engine is going to work. You can prove that by comparing a 23 degree cast iron Chevy head that has the same CSA as a high port 15 or 18 degree head. The high port head will make a lot more power even though the CSA is the same. The Wallace calculator doesn't take that into account. Shape is really important when talking about choke point.
Think of it in aero terms. Coefficient of drag is a different factor than frontal area. You can have a small car that has high drag numbers or you can have a big car with good drag numbers. The CSA is just the frontal area term. You still need to know shape before you know how the port is going to work.
Short summary is don't pay too much attention to CSA and choke point unless you have a well refined head program. If you are a NASCAR shop and all of your heads have the same shape but the CSA varies from head to head then you probably can figure out what the choke point will be. If you're just picking random heads out of the Summit catalog for a bracket race car then the calculated choke point isn't going to be all that accurate of a number.
Andy F.
AR Engineering
AR Engineering
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
it shouldn't be called "choke" because what you are referring to is not "choked flow" (in most cases) which has specific meaning in fluid flow and in most cases people get confused
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
People getting confused is their own problem. if "math says" you can't pass .5 mach it's because your math is not realizing the density drops. that is the speed going IN, not the speed coming out.
Cars are going into the traffic jam at 10 mph, leaving at 60. As soon as they see open road they hit the gas, and thus they become farther apart. The faster they go the farther they are apart, but the through-put, in cars per minute, or in molecules per minute, is the same. throughout the road. I know people don't understand it because if they did they would drive less stupid. If a three lane road goes down to two lanes, you gotta speed up! That's the only way your gonna fit this many cars THROUGH a smaller road. And if the road goes from three lanes to two, you can slow down. Instead, they do the opposite, and the result is any day now my tiny car is going to be sandwiched under a truck.
There has to be a smallest point, and it should be placed wisely. The cars come out of the traffic jam, accelerate, and then a sharp turn? fork in the road? can't be good The tail of a venturi is usually 5-7 degrees, can't diffuse it much faster than that. They can't change lanes any faster than a 1/4 inch per inch. Each piece is not terribly hard to understand, but the whole of them is complex indeed.
Cars are going into the traffic jam at 10 mph, leaving at 60. As soon as they see open road they hit the gas, and thus they become farther apart. The faster they go the farther they are apart, but the through-put, in cars per minute, or in molecules per minute, is the same. throughout the road. I know people don't understand it because if they did they would drive less stupid. If a three lane road goes down to two lanes, you gotta speed up! That's the only way your gonna fit this many cars THROUGH a smaller road. And if the road goes from three lanes to two, you can slow down. Instead, they do the opposite, and the result is any day now my tiny car is going to be sandwiched under a truck.
There has to be a smallest point, and it should be placed wisely. The cars come out of the traffic jam, accelerate, and then a sharp turn? fork in the road? can't be good The tail of a venturi is usually 5-7 degrees, can't diffuse it much faster than that. They can't change lanes any faster than a 1/4 inch per inch. Each piece is not terribly hard to understand, but the whole of them is complex indeed.
Last edited by modok on Sun Jun 24, 2018 3:33 am, edited 1 time in total.
Re: What happens at the “choke” point?
Ok, then what is this math and what does it say?
Looks like 0.6
I have heard assumptions from .5 to as high as .7
This is probably an adjustment to calibrate the results to reality, but as basic theory, .5 makes good sense.
Looks like 0.6
I have heard assumptions from .5 to as high as .7
This is probably an adjustment to calibrate the results to reality, but as basic theory, .5 makes good sense.